• • 
    The Reverend Jose Cruz Alvarez
    Pastor
  • 
    The Reverend Joseph E Franco
    2010 - 2021
  • 
    The Reverend Michael P Sepp †
    2000 - 2009 (Died on March 13, 2009)
  • 
    The Reverend Mark Cregan, CSC
    1992 - 2000
  • 
    The Reverend Joseph Callahan, CSC †
    1990 - 1992 (Died on April 21, 2019)
  • 
    The Reverend Monsignor Peter F O'Donnell
    1981 - 1990
  • 
    The Reverend Monsignor Henry J Lenahan †
    1966 - 1981 (Died on May 15, 1991)
  • 
    The Reverend Monsignor William Humphrey, PA †
    1934 - 1965 (Died on November 7, 1965)
  • 
    The Reverend Peter F Guinevan †
    1928 - 1934 (Died on January 1, 1934)
  • 
    The Reverend John J Lennon †
    1908 - 1928 (Died on February 11, 1928)
  • 
    The Reverend James A Mullen †
    1876 - 1907 (Died on December 21, 1907)